Skip to main content

Table 2 Model performance for the EN, RSF, benchmark and combined (quantitative imaging features and benchmark) models

From: Radiomics for therapy-specific head and neck squamous cell carcinoma survival prognostication (part I)

Cohort

AUC test

95% CI

AUC train

95% CI

p(test) vs RSF

p(test) vs Benchmark or combined

EN

 Complete

0.711

0.695–0.728

0.799

0.793–0.805

0.002

 < 0.001

 Surgery

0.672

0.627–0.718

0.778

0.751–0.804

0.938

 < 0.001

 RCTX

0.560

0.527–0.593

0.827

0.808–0.846

 < 0.001

0.420

 RT

0.585

0.516–0.653

0.778

0.748–0.808

0.158

0.434

EN Benchmark

 Complete

0.632

0.613–0.650

0.745

0.730–0.760

  

 Surgery

0.445

0.404–0.486

0.772

0.741–0.804

  

 RCTX

0.578

0.546–0.611

0.789

0.771–0.808

  

 RT

0.621

0.560–0.681

0.776

0.751–0.801

  

RSF

 Complete

0.746

0.731–0.760

0.948

0.946–0.949

 

 < 0.001

 Surgery

0.675

0.629–0.721

0.950

0.946–0.954

 

0.006

 RCTX

0.652

0.622–0.681

0.938

0.935–0.942

 

0.002

 RT

0.507

0.422–0.591

0.897

0.887–0.907

 

 < 0.001

RSF Benchmark

 Complete

0.669

0.651–0.686

0.827

0.823–0.830

  

 Surgery

0.578

0.526–0.630

0.809

0.797–0.821

  

 RCTX

0.575

0.538–0.613

0.858

0.852–0.865

  

 RT

0.788

0.734–0.842

0.818

0.803–0.833

  

EN combined

 Complete

0.799

0.793–0.805

0.798

0.792–0.805

 < 0.001

0.065

 Surgery

0.645

0.604–0.685

0.795

0.770–0.819

0.335

0.369

 RCTX

0.555

0.525–0.586

0.842

0.820–0.864

 < 0.001

0.853

 RT

0.595

0.527–0.664

0.833

0.803–0.864

0.601

0.828

RSF combined

 Complete

0.759

0.745–0.772

0.949

0.948–0.951

 

0.215

 Surgery

0.673

0.632–0.714

0.953

0.947–0.958

 

0.944

 RCTX

0.650

0.615–0.684

0.943

0.939–0.956

 

0.924

 RT

0.568

0.488–0.647

0.904

0.895–0.912

 

0.298

  1. The Cox-Survival (Harrel's) C (AUC) with the respective confidence interval is shown for each model and subgroup for the training and test dataset. For statistical analysis two-sided, independent Student’s t-test was performed comparing the iterated AUC values of the test dataset
  2. AUC Cox-Survival (Harrel’s) C, EN Elastic net, RCTX Radiochemotherapy, RT Radiotherapy, RSF Random survival forest