Skip to main content

Table 5 Interobserver agreement between the CNN and the radiologists

From: The efficacy of deep learning models in the diagnosis of endometrial cancer using MRI: a comparison with radiologists

  

Reader 1

Reader 2

Reader 3

Axial ADC

CNN

0.410 (SD0.090)

0.515 (SD0.083)

0.443 (SD0.091)

 

Reader2

0.558 (SD0.085)

 

Reader3

0.629 (SD0.078)

0.609 (SD0.079)

Axial T2WI

CNN

0.496 (SD0.083)

0.322 (SD0.087)

0.493 (SD0.084)

 

Reader2

0.584 (SD0.085)

 

Reader3

0.702 (SD0.073)

0.546 (SD0.086)

Sagittal T2WI

CNN

0.483 (SD0.080)

0.453 (SD0.087)

0.450 (SD0.088)

 

Reader2

0.722 (SD0.071)

 

Reader3

0.598 (SD0.081)

0.624 (SD0.080)

Axial CE-T1WI

CNN

0.690 (SD0.073)

0.773 (SD0.064)

0.690 (SD0.073)

 

Reader2

0.874 (SD0.050)

 

Reader3

0.832 (SD0.057)

0.833 (SD0.057)

Sagittal CE-T1WI

CNN

0.654 (SD0.074)

0.576 (SD0.078)

0.567 (SD0.083)

 

Reader2

0.831 (SD0.057)

 

Reader3

0.794 (SD0.061)

0.712 (SD0.070)

Combined axial T2WI + ADC

CNN

0.335 (SD0.055)

0.412 (SD0.054)

0.339 (SD0.055)

 

Reader2

0.727 (SD0.070)

 

Reader3

0.714 (SD0.069)

0.774 (SD0.063)

Combined axial T2WI + CE-T1WI

CNN

0.814 (SD0.059)

0.752 (SD0.067)

0.651 (SD0.076)

 

Reader2

0.853 (SD0.053)

 

Reader3

0.756 (SD0.064)

0.695 (SD0.071)

Combined sagittal T2WI + CE-T1WI

CNN

0.604 (SD0.081)

0.453 (SD0.089)

0.609 (SD0.080)

 

Reader2

0.807 (SD0.060)

 

Reader3

0.836 (SD0.055)

0.693 (SD0.069)

Combined axial T2WI + ADC + CE-T1WI

CNN

0.550 (SD0.081)

0.469 (SD0.084)

0.486 (SD0.088)

 

Reader2

0.777 (SD0.067)

 

Reader3

0.724 (SD0.070)

0.765 (SD0.065)

  1. ADC, Apparent Diffusion Coefficient; T2WI, T2 weighted image; CE-T1WI, contrast-enhanced T1 weighted image; SD, standard deviations