Skip to main content

Table 6 Overview of low-value imaging in the spine, pelvis, and hip

From: Characterizing and quantifying low-value diagnostic imaging internationally: a scoping review

Type of imaging

Reason for examination

Outcome

Suggested practice by included study/studies

References

L-spine XR, CT, MRI

Low back pain

Low rate in change of management

MRI: 41.3% relevant findings

 

[121,122,123,124,125,126,127,128,129,130]

Post-op L or C-spine XR

Instrumented single-level degenerative spinal fusions

Does not change treatment of patient

Check with fluoroscopy during surgery

[132]

Post-op L-spine XR

Lumbar fusion

0–1% relevant findings

XR if positive physical examination only

[133, 134]

Spine XR

Acute neck or back pain

0.4% relevant findings

 

[131]

Pelvic XR

Sever trauma

No change in management

 

[91]

CT/MRI pelvis

Pelvic ring fracture

No change in management

 

[135]

Routine Pelvic XR

Pelvic fracture

No change in management in patients with painless straight leg raise

Among awake, alert patients without spinal or lower limb injury, painless straight leg raise can exclude pelvic fractures

[136]

Trauma

10% change in management

XR if positive physical examination only

[137]

Post-op Hip XR

Hip hemiarthroplasty

No change in management

XR if positive physical examination only

[138]

Hip fracture

No change in management

XR if positive physical examination only

[139]

MRI Hip

Hip pain

After XR—low impact on treatment

 

[140]

  1. XR X-ray, CT computed tomography, MRI magnetic resonance imaging