From: An evaluation of performance measures for arterial brain vessel segmentation
Overall correlation results (Visual scores 1–10) | Correlation results of good quality simulated segmentation variations (Visual scores 1–5) | Correlation results of bad quality simulated segmentation variations (Visual scores 6–10) | ||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Rank | Performance Measure | rho | Rank | Performance measure | rho | Rank | Performance measure | rho |
1 | bAHD | 0.956 | 1 | bAHD | 0.817 | 1 | bAHD | 0.894 |
2 | AHD | 0.950 | 2 | AHD | 0.800 | 2 | AHD | 0.880 |
3 | RI | 0.936 | 3 | VOI | 0.758 | 3 | VOI | 0.872 |
3 | ACC | 0.936 | 4 | GCE | 0.757 | 3 | GCE | 0.872 |
3 | GCE | 0.936 | 5 | ACC | 0.754 | 5 | ARI | 0.865 |
3 | VOI | 0.936 | 5 | RI | 0.754 | 5 | ACC | 0.865 |
7 | ARI | 0.932 | 7 | KAP | 0.742 | 5 | RI | 0.865 |
7 | KAP | 0.932 | 7 | ARI | 0.742 | 8 | KAP | 0.864 |
7 | PBD | 0.932 | 7 | PBD | 0.742 | 8 | PBD | 0.864 |
7 | DICE | 0.932 | 7 | DICE | 0.742 | 8 | DICE | 0.864 |
7 | ICC | 0.932 | 7 | ICC | 0.742 | 8 | JAC | 0.864 |
7 | JAC | 0.932 | 7 | JAC | 0.742 | 8 | CNF | 0.864 |
7 | CNF | 0.932 | 7 | CNF | 0.742 | 8 | ICC | 0.864 |
14 | PRC | 0.858 | 14 | PRC | 0.709 | 14 | PRC | 0.802 |
15 | SP | 0.820 | 15 | SP | 0.683 | 15 | SP | 0.714 |
15 | SB | 0.820 | 15 | SB | 0.683 | 15 | SB | 0.714 |
17 | MI | 0.755 | 17 | MHD | 0.621 | 17 | VS | 0.532 |
18 | MHD | 0.728 | 18 | MI | 0.595 | 18 | MI | 0.426 |
19 | VS | 0.722 | 19 | VS | 0.555 | 19 | MHD | 0.343 |
20 | HD95 | 0.418 | 20 | HD95 | 0.359 | 20 | HD95 | 0.259 |
21 | AUC | 0.378 | 21 | AUC | 0.271 | 21 | AUC | 0.142 |
22 | SNS | 0.314 | 22 | SNS | 0.212 | 22 | SNS | 0.104 |